The Other Refugee Crisis: Cubans in Costa Rica

I just arrived in Northwest Costa Rica for a short vacation hoping to photograph at most one or two monkeys and if lucky an elusive sloth. However, on the way from the airport to my hotel, I learned that the Costa Rican government currently has a migrant crisis of its own that has not received as much press coverage as the one in Europe. Thousands of Cubans hoping to emigrate to the US via Ecuador have been stranded in Costa Rica since November 14 when the Nicaraguan government decided to close their border with Costa Rica to Cubans, preventing them from continuing their journey further North. As was described in an editorial of the NYT earlier this week (http://www.nytimes.com/2015/12/21/opinion/a-new-cuban-exodus.html), these Cubans have decided to attempt this long journey to the US now because of “the hopelessness at home and the fear that the unique treatment Cuban immigrants receive from Washington could end” given the recent thaw in Cuban American relation.

So the sloth and the monkeys (and my husband) will have to wait a little longer. Today I went to La Cruz, a small town about 20 kilometers from the Nicaraguan border where the Cubans have been staying since the border shutdown. It is heart wrenching. Every story I heard was tragic. I am told that over seven thousand Cubans (and still more arriving every day) are now in La Cruz, a large group of them living around the church premises, many of them in shelters made of plastic sheets. They have been in La Cruz for over 45 days with nothing to do other than waiting, not knowing what is in the cards for them, sitting or lying down on the foam mattress that were giving to each of them in what is now their home. Two couples told me about attempting to cross into Nicaragua illegally in desperation, only to end up being caught and sent back to Costa Rica with their money taken. One of the wives was sobbing uncontrollably as they were telling me the story.

Still people tried to keep up hope and go on with daily activities to keep a semblance of normality. The shelter gets cleaned by a group of Cuban women daily; men are getting their hair cut; and children are trying to study or play with whatever they can find. I also noticed that, though many Cubans are not religious, many of them wear a rosary that has been given to them by the church, maybe a sign of their hopelessness. Of course this is just one more human tragedy among many others. Somehow the fact that I was in Cuba exactly a year ago (A New Day In Cuba, Making Friends in Cuba) makes this particularly upsetting to me as I met people from some of the villages I visited at that time: Camaguey, Holguin, Santiago, and of course Havana. A man with a white beard explained to me that he used to be a Hemingway impersonator for tourists in Havana. I may well have seen him there.

I understand that this is not an easy situation politically but it is one that I hope will be resolved quickly. Let’s hope for a  miracle. It’s the season!

Happy Holidays everyone.

France

CubanMigrants_(1_of_11)Cuban migrants stranded in La Cruz, Costa Rica after the Nicaraguan government denied them access, preventing them for pursuing their journey further North.

 

CubanMigrants_(2_of_11)Make-shift shelters have been erected to house the thousands of Cuban migrants stranded in La Cruz, Costa Rica.

 

CubanMigrants_(3_of_11)Some of the shelters housing the Cuban migrants are made of huge plastic sheets.

 

CubanMigrants_(4_of_11)This young Cuban  has been waiting for over a month and a half in La Cruz, Costa Rica with many fellow Cubans.

 

CubanMigrants_(5_of_11)These two women and their families have attempted to cross the Nicaraguan border multiple times only to be send back to Costa Rica.

 

CubanMigrants_(6_of_11)Cuban women have organized a thorough cleaning system to keep the shelters at their best.

 

CubanMigrants_(7_of_11)A Cuban barber has found customers among the stranded migrants.

 

CubanMigrants_(8_of_11)This young girl play with an old beach shoe to keep herself busy.

 

CubanMigrants_(9_of_11)This man used to work as an impersonator of Ernest Hemingway in Old Havana. He is now hoping to live in in Hemingway’s home country.

 

CubanMigrants_(10_of_11)Riot police have been added to the Nicaraguan border.

 

CubanMigrants_(11_of_11)Nativity scene at the La Cruz church in Costa Rica. La Cruz is the town where thousands of Cuban migrants are now stranded.

This entry was posted in Costa Rica, Photography and tagged , , , , , , .

15 Comments

  1. Elise December 23, 2015 at 14:15 #

    So….where are the monkey photos???

    • franceleclerc December 23, 2015 at 18:30 #

      No time for monkeys yet, maybe tomorrow but they are all over. I think they grow in trees here 😉 Costa Rica is your type of places, they have a million birds. You probably have been here already. Warm holiday wishes, France

  2. Sally Bucko December 23, 2015 at 14:42 #

    Another tragedy in a world that seems to have mostly turned it’s back on so much suffering! Thank you for documenting this story, France!

    • franceleclerc December 23, 2015 at 18:31 #

      Thank you for reading it Sally. Warm holiday wishes to you and your family. France

  3. michele December 23, 2015 at 18:37 #

    Interesting story. Strong photos! Happy Holidays!

    • franceleclerc December 24, 2015 at 07:07 #

      Another tragic situation. How sad! Happy Holidays to you Michele.

  4. Sara Levinson December 25, 2015 at 16:28 #

    It’s so like you to find and bring attention to a relevant human story. Great photos. Thanks for sharing. Can’t help but wonder how it will affect my view of Cuba next months, when I get to go there.
    If you can get to San Jose for the “Parade Of Horses”, a very festive and happy Costa Rican tradition, it’s guaranteed to lift your spirits.

    • franceleclerc December 25, 2015 at 18:33 #

      Sara, Thanks for reading. Yes, another tragic situation with no solutions in sight. And it is getting worse as thousand more Cubans are now at the border between Costa Rica and Panama and now the Costa Rican government won’t let them in until the situation is resolved. And every story is heart wrenching. I would have liked to photograph more but the police basically asked me to leave. You will have a great time in Cuba, Cuban people are beautiful and warm. They just would like their life to be a bit easier and I don’t blame them. I won’t make the Parade of Horses in San Jose as I am about a 5 hour drive from there near Liberia. Maybe next year 😉 Warm holidays wishes.

  5. Emilie December 26, 2015 at 05:44 #

    ” 1 in every 122 humans is today someone who has been forced to flee their homes,” according to the U.N. This is a figure that is hard to imagine.
    I had not heard anything about this Cuban/Costa Rica crisis so thanks for the story and photos.
    The young child playing while another is cocooned in the roll-up mattress…the waiting in limbo would be intolerable .
    I like your hope for a Christmas miracle.
    Leaders of countries have the power to make things better and I ponder most days what exactly is holding them back.My own country seems stuck in some ideology over how to help refugees and who is a refugee 🙁
    Despite it all we see a simple nativity scene like the one you photographed in many of the refugee hot spots..Calais, Syria ,Turkey ,CAR ..quite incredible .

    • franceleclerc January 1, 2016 at 14:15 #

      Dear Emilie, Thank you for reading and caring. I hadn’t heard of the Cuban crisis in Costa Rica either until I got there, I do not think many people have. The Christmas miracle did not happen but we can still hope for a timely resolution. It was heart breaking visit, that is for sure. Wishing you all the best for the New Year. Let’s hope the word rallies and finds a solution for all of these people that had to flee their home. They deserve it.

  6. Nevada Wier December 31, 2015 at 12:49 #

    oh my! good for you France! I’m going to share this story.

  7. Jeremy Woodhouse December 31, 2015 at 21:50 #

    It is amazing what goes on in this world which is unreported. Great story! On a parallel note I recently met a Japanese photographer who lives in BC, Canada who has been documenting the Japanese in Cuba many of whom were sent there during WW2. Apparently he only knows of one secon generation Japanes man left who is now 102. Happy New Year!

    • franceleclerc January 1, 2016 at 14:24 #

      Yes, even in our world of social media where everything seems to be overdocumented, there are still untold stories or some that get lost. It was one of these heart-breaking situations where you really wish you could help but have no clue what you can do. I like your story of the Japanese in Cuba. Wouldn’t it be great to meet this older gentleman? He must have so much to tell. Happy New Year to you, Jeremy.

Post a Comment

Your email is never published nor shared. Required fields are marked *

*
*